Pacifiers vs. Teeth: When to Say Goodbye Before Treatment Starts

For new parents, few tools offer peace and quiet like a trusty pacifier. They're soothing, comforting, and sometimes the only solution for a sleepy, fussy baby. But as helpful as pacifiers can be in the early weeks and months, they can eventually impact your child’s dental development, especially if they’re still using one as they approach toddlerhood.

At Saginaw Kids Dentistry, Dr. Christina and Dr. Elias understand from both clinical experience and parenthood how comforting pacifiers can be, but also when it's best to say goodbye for the sake of your child’s smile

How Pacifiers Affect Developing Teeth

Pacifiers may be a source of calm right now, but prolonged use can impact the way your child's teeth and jaws grow. This is especially important before your little one begins any dental treatments or interceptive orthodontic care.

Our goal isn’t to create fear. Instead, we want to provide families with honest, expert guidance so they can make the best decisions for long-term oral health. Here are some of the most common dental issues linked to prolonged pacifier use:

Open bite: The upper and lower front teeth don't meet properly when the mouth is closed.
Overjet: Also known as "buck teeth," where the upper front teeth stick out too far forward.
Palatal changes: The roof of the mouth may narrow, affecting the alignment of adult teeth later on.
Speech delays: Extended pacifier use may contribute to difficulties with articulation and pronunciation.

Dr. Christina and Dr. Elias approach every child’s situation with individualized care, offering guidance while honoring the emotional needs of your child, and yours.

When to Transition Away from the Pacifier

Timing matters. Pacifier use is not a big deal before your child has all of their baby teeth, but once they have a full set of teeth, continued sucking on a pacifier can interfere with jaw development, palate expansion, and adult tooth eruption.

Most kids stop using pacifiers on their own between the ages of 12-18 months. However, if your child doesn’t stop using a pacifier on their own, The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD) generally recommends beginning the transition away from pacifiers by the age of three at the latest.

How to Wean Without the Tears

We know this part sounds tough for many families. But you can confidently start this transition with a few kid-friendly strategies that minimize distress and make the process feel more like a milestone than a loss. Try these gentle weaning methods:

Dropping the daytime pacifier: Start by only allowing pacifier use during naps and bedtime, then gradually reduce night use as well.
"Binky fairy" approach: Let your child "donate" or "exchange" the pacifier for a toy or certificate from the mythical Binky Fairy.
Visual progress charts: Celebrate pacifier-free days with stickers or small rewards to keep motivation high.

Both Dr. Elias and Dr. Christina are more than happy to offer weaning advice tailored to your child’s age and temperament. As board-certified pediatric dentists and parents themselves, they bring both professional guidance and an empathetic touch to support your family's journey.

What to Expect at Their First Post-Pacifier Visit

Saying goodbye to pacifiers is a significant step, and it's the perfect time for a check-in with your pediatric dental team. At your child’s next visit, we’ll gently evaluate how thumb or pacifier use may have affected their bite and provide recommendations in a fun and reassuring way.

Our office in Saginaw is fully kid-centric, with comfort-driven details like calming décor, iPad stations, and TVs overhead to keep children relaxed during their visit. We may also:

Assess overall oral development and alignment
Monitor spacing and eruptions of baby teeth
Discuss long-term orthodontic considerations, if needed

Because Saginaw Kids Dentistry prioritizes conservative, minimally invasive care, we guide treatment decisions thoughtfully, always balancing clinical expertise with your child’s comfort and emotional wellness.

Schedule Your Child’s Next Dental Visit in Saginaw

If you're considering helping your little one transition away from their pacifier, or you’ve already begun, we’d love to partner with you during this exciting milestone. At Saginaw Kids Dentistry, our board-certified team is here to make every child feel safe, welcome, and genuinely excited about caring for their smile. Call us today at (682) 285-1900 to schedule your visit in Saginaw. Let’s set your child up for a future of healthy, happy teeth, together.

Back to blogs

Welcome to Saginaw Kids Dentistry

Learn More!

How Do I Know If My Child Has a Tongue or Lip Tie? Everything You Need To Know!

Learn More!

Become a Part of OUR Family Today!

At the heart of Saginaw Kids Dentistry is our passion for meeting families, seeing them grow, and being a trustworthy presence for kids and parents alike. If you’re ready to join our patient family, book a visit online today! We are excited to meet you and your child.

Book a Visit

Blog